Tuesday, January 14, 2014

The Pill, Obamacare, and You

     To say that contraception is a touchy issue in American politics is more of an understatement than saying that the Titanic suffered from a "small leak." The recent healthcare reform bill, spearheaded by the Obama administration, hasn't helped matters at all. The Affordable Care Act contains a clause that requires that employer-offered insurance programs must offer contraceptive coverage without a copay. Although religious employers such as churches are exempt from this clause, religiously affiliated charities, colleges, and hospitals are not, the reason being that people working, for example, at St. Mary's Hospital in Madison are not necessarily affiliated with the church, whereas people employed by a church or other place of worship are. This has caused an uproar (actually only a few complaints from a small number of people) in the religious community, as many (a few) employers argue that offering contraception to their employees goes against their religious beliefs. 
     Consider if you will the example of the Little Sisters of the Poor. According to their mission statement, "The Little Sisters of the Poor are an international congregation of Roman Catholic women religious founded in 1839 by Saint Jeanne Jugan. Together with a diverse network of collaborators, [they] serve the elderly poor in over 30 countries around the world." Under the mandate, the Little Sisters are not exempt as a religious group. Their case was taken to court, where a judge ruled that they would not have to offer their employees contraceptives through their insurance. One would think that the story should end there; they're a group of nuns, and obviously directly affiliated with the church. It seems that their case should fall more to the "church," and therefore, exempt part of the law rather than the "church-adjacent." A judge, realizing this, decided to rule them exempt from the law. End of story, right? Except it isn't; many republicans are using that specific example as a justification for exempting all church-affiliated employers, no matter how superficial the affiliation is. Some are even arguing that there is reason enough to remove the mandate altogether.
     Before we get too far into the politics of contraceptives like "the pill," it's important to know exactly what they are and what they do. Yes, they are obviously used to prevent pregnancies, but their medical use doesn't end there. According to WebMD, other uses for the pill include lower cancer risk, clearer skin, less painful periods, PMS relief, and relief of "endometriosos, a condition in which uterine-lining tissue grows in other pelvic areas, can lead to scarring, severe pain, and sometimes infertility. The Pill stops the growth of tissue in other areas by reducing the hormones that cause the lining to build up." There are many people that use the pill not to stop pregnancies, but because it is vital to their health that they do so. Why should they be deprived of their medicine because they chose to seek employment at a place that happens to be affiliated with the church, even if they themselves aren't?
     The biggest issue with the entire contraceptive debate, however, is the people who are actually doing the debating. The people in charge of deciding this issue which literally only affects women is congress, a group made up primarily of old, white men (only a little over 18% of congress is female -- a record high. And the average age of a senator? 62). Any sane person should question the fact that an issue affecting almost entirely young women is being decided by the oldest, male-est institution since the Hair Club for Men. That's like Mexico deciding whether or not America could have any McDonald's restaurants -- that is, if a lack of McDoubles with extra pickles had the possibility of causing excruciating pain and infertility.
     Access to contraception is certainly a complex issue that shows no intentions of becoming less complex in the near future. We as a country can, however be smarter in the way we approach the issue. The national news has dissolved into a partisan echo chamber -- both on the left and the right -- that works to further divide people on the issue by only presenting information that affirms the beliefs of their viewers rather than presenting all the evidence or, god forbid, challenging the public to consider the merits of viewpoints that aren't their own. Until there is an intelligent, thoughtful debate, there can't and won't be any progress.

No comments:

Post a Comment